NEW HOPE INTERNATIONAL REVIEW ON-LINE

www
Blithe Spirit
12 Eliot Vale
Blackheath
London
SE3 0UW
UK
ISSN 1353-3320
£5
Subscriptions: £20 pa [£22 Europe; £25 or US$36 RoW]
visit British Haiku Society's Website read reviews of later issues.

www
Before commenting on this review please read the FAQ page

Home page
Notes for publishers
Want to be a reviewer?

Anthologies.
Books.
Audio.
Magazines.
Software.
Video.
Artefacts.

Web design by Gerald England
This page last updated: 28th March 2005.
Blithe Spirit Vol.12 #4

Martin Lucas' 'dream' haibun, HAGGIS, in this issue, is something of an apologia for all overworked poetry editors (Lucas edits Presence). At his left-hand is a red-inked stamp pad and in his 'right-hand is a stamp that says HAIKU". He is standing by a conveyor belt sorting edible meat, 'the size of small footballs', from the inedible. As these rather formless, plastic covered balls 'chug past' they get stamped — the others are given a 'forceful nudge' into a bin. There seems no end to this work: 'stamp, stamp, nudge, nudge, stamp...' I won't spoil it for the reader by giving away the end haiku. Well, faced with literally hundreds, if not thousands of submissions even the most stalwart of editors must wonder when 'the shift will end'. Reviewers can feel like this too! — so it's always a shot in the arm to receive a magazine to review that you know is going to be stimulating.

The very feel of Blithe Spirit is good — substantial, but manageable. Its pages are filled with poems that represent what is going on in Haiku and Haibun, etc., now. Colin Blundell's editorship does not disappoint (despite that 'long shift').

Here are two poems that share a similar subject but are very different: one ruminative, slow burning; the other matter-of-fact, almost humorously observed, despite its implications.

	Outside the hospital
	stubbed out cigarettes
	still smouldering
	
	Maureen 0'Sullivan

		outpatients'
		his medical file thicker
		than his wrists

		David Cobb
Blithe Spirit has always had stimulating and often learned articles on its menu and this issue is no exception — Annie Bachini's clarification of 'surreal haiku'; Martin Lucas' elegant examination of 'non-dualistic metaphor; Stephen Henry Gill's reportage of what's going in Japan (haiku-wise).

This issue features two pages of tanka. Here is a particularly fine one from Leslie Giddens on which to end:

	zillion empty rice bowls
	full of the world's hunger
	yet why do you & I
	resist our heart's desire
	for something more

reviewer: Michael Bangerter.
Blithe Spirit Vol.13 #1

This is a surreal issue of the well-established magazine — or rather it is an organized and thoughtful exploration of surreal haiku, with a lot more besides. In her editorial, Annie Bachini explains that the pursuit of the unusual is inevitably an experiment, and sensibly implies that it will be for the reader to decide which are the 'surreal and more familiar forms of haiku'.

One might suspect the magazine to be creaking under the positive weight of the readers' responses to the theme. It's not quite that simple, since the whole serves as a search for definition via its parts. Not surprisingly, there is an intention to have a 'surreal section' in the next issue, so that the explorations in this one can be refined.

In any case, Stanley Pelter is one of several contributors who offers a helpful thumbnail essay on the theme, embedded in which are some useful signposts for where to find surrealism in BLITHE SPIRIT. For example:

The surrealist image is manufactured by the chance juxtaposition of two different realities, and it is on the spark struck by their meeting that the beauty of the image depends.
Perhaps this is most obvious in the visual medium, but plenty of poets have recognised the necessary (lack of?) rules, notably Pelter himself, with images Magritte might have conceived:
	a rook sleeps with her
	slowly he tears at his watch
	until tears appear.
Questions are left unanswered here, but they are interesting questions, like the ones put by A. A. Marcoff, ripe with grim suggestion:
	a butterfly flits
	from grave to grave
	out of my mouth
	the naked and the dead.
Klaus-Dieter Wirth's contributions illuminate the theme to varying degrees, particularly when he mixes the visual with the suggested:
	Forget-me-knots and
	the daily ration of tobacco
	as burial gifts.
Ian Turner and Colin Blundell offer entertaining and more controversial prose essays on surrealistic haiku. Turner engages as he faithfully explores the
Dadaist/Surrealist strategy of exploiting chance as a method of composition.
The results are random snippets from the press, for example:
          On the map/ an attractive birch veneer/ improves breathing.
Their prosaic layout keeps Turner's experiments in perspective and remind us of the different impact of the apparently and the genuinely random. Much of developed surrealism was, presumably, about connecting the ostensibly unconnected, with the conviction that this would impact on the viewer or reader.

Colin Blundell sees it another way. By unearthing Dadaist writings, he undermines the new surrealistic haiku writers, by arguing that the originals

are not far removed from the poems of the self-proclaimed haiku avant-garde.
He cites a number of examples from around 1916, including:
	the cockatoo
	under the skirts of the Spanish dancer
	sings sadly like a headquarters bugler
Interestingly, there is a greater metaphorical logic and impact to a couple of the historical examples, particularly this one:
	only the fire department
	can drive the nightmare from the drawing room
	but all the hoses are broken.
At this point, it is tempting to see the wider impact of the surreal, within and without this issue of BLITHE SPIRIT. At one end of a spectrum there is the power of randomness, rarely achieved in the original writing here, although Francis Attard succeeds:
	stripper shapes a room
	moon lifts over a lobster pot
	skewer a sky.
Conversely, there are those poems throughout the journal which capture moments from a recognisable world, which we can imagine and enjoy because they are not surreal. Here's an example by Jean Jorgensen:
	radiant sunset
	beyond the ripening grain
	burnt-out poplars
The Surrealists, and the Dadaists have given us the ability to operate and appreciate at a middle level in this spectrum, specifically in those cases where a flurry of words coalesces in a moment of arbitrariness. Steven McGarry is one of many who achieves this:
	in the flower shop
	the tattooed biker
	looks lost
Ron Woollard is another, using sharply-formed metaphor, rather than ingenious incongruity, achieving a special moment of simple affection:
	Catching your laugh
		I snap it up tight and safe
	in a black spool.
Writing surreally is therefore proven to be rather more difficult than BLITHE SPIRIT staff might have originally supposed, and one reason might be the ecomonies of scale of the haiku form. However, this underlines the importance of the magazine's venture in that direction. Like punk rock, surrealism broke up the formal foundations and left a space upon which new artists could build. In BLITHE SPIRIT, such artists abound.

reviewer: Will Daunt.
Blithe Spirit Vol.13 #3

This issue has excellent articles by Stanley Pelter and Giovanni Malito on the surreal in haiku, following on apparently from explorations of the subject in earlier issues. One of the reasons I like haiku is that it can have a surreal aspect, so it is good to see this aspect being explored in a thoughtful way.

In the main part of the magazine, Andrew Detheridge has a haiku with a surreal tinge to it:

	blue sky:
	so full of mountain
	so full of silence
I liked this one in the "surreal" section by Thom Williams:
	winter passing
	in the time it takes
	to light the fire
Yasuhiko Shigemoto adds an sf element to the surreal:
	Ants digging
	their holes deeper and deeper
	for atomic war
David Cobb has an excellent article on the "English Line" in poetry and English Haiku. This came about as a result of his reading John Powell Ward's THE ENGLISH LINE; POETRY OF THE UNPOETIC FROM WORDSWORTH TO LARKIN (Macmillan, 1991). It's a concept that deserves further investigation, I hope that David Cobb's essay will inspire others to look at it as well.

BLITHE SPIRIT is a thought-provoking magazine which is not afraid to explore the wider poetic world and try to relate it to the world of haiku.

reviewer: John Francis Haines.
Blithe Spirit Vol.13 #4

Another rich and varied helping from the British Haiku Society. This is a tasty batch for mind and imagination — also the eye. There's something deeply satisfying about crisp stanzas descending through the void of the page. It has the flavour of Zen painting.

Quality control is set high across the entire range of forms. Haiku mix with senryu, are grouped into meditations on Autumn, and appear in the five-seven-five form. There are linked sequences, renga and haibun. It's undesirable to single any out for special attention, but AAMarcoff opens the Journal with a haiku which might serve as an emblem, in its immediacy and its elusiveness.

	a butterfly appears
	when there seems no hope
	to speak of
The theory side of the journal attempts to pin that butterfly quality down. Willem J. van der Molen called it
the presentation of a mysterious surplus that is suitable to turn common words into poetry.
Klaus-Dieter Wirth continues an appreciation of van der Molen's work, showing the development of his thought and his attempt at a typology of haiku. Elsewhere, Jesse Peel considers the role of literary allusion, or intertextuality.

The article that strikes the most sparks, however, is Alison Williams' exploration of the alchemy of haiku. Like the haikuist, the alchemist is concerned with evidence and experience. These are practical, if obscure, arts. Both subscribe to the notion of correspondence; as above, so below. As Williams puts it, haiku

seeks to discern the shared essential qualities in natural phenomena and in the human being's inward experience.
This can be extended further still. Alchemy and haiku work in the realm of the prima materia, the everyday world, and seek transformation through the resolution of opposites — the fleeting and the eternal, subject and object. Lead is transmuted to gold, common words into poetry. Of necessity, this transformation includes the haiku alchemist themselves.

The alchemists of BLITHE SPIRIT offer new haiku and new ways of looking at haiku. Highly recommended.

reviewer: Ian Sherred.