![]() Envoi 44 Rudyard Road, Biddulph Moor, Stoke on Trent, ST8 7JN, UK £5 [$10] Subscriptions: 3 issues £15 [£20 overseas: $40 in US dollar bills] read reviews of later issues ![]() Before commenting on this review please read the FAQ page Home page Notes for publishers Want to be a reviewer? Anthologies. Books. Audio. Magazines. Software. Video. Artefacts. Web design by Gerald England This page last updated: 17th April 2004. |
Envoi #134 | |
|
ENVOI will need no introduction to most readers of poetry magazines, having established a solid reputation since its beginnings in 1957. The poetry that lingers most in my mind from this issue is Sally Festing's sequence from THE DONER'S DAUGHTER, in which she writes about the long term emotional effects of sperm donation. Sally Festing will know something herself about this, having grown up with a father who was one of the earliest doners: I remember you saying in that half-shy proud excited boyish way your sperm was super charged.What is especially powerful about this sequence, however, is that different sections look at the subject from the different perspectives of the many people involved, from the doctor who looks down the microscope thinking about the doner who each week slides his prick between his fingersto the children of the sperm doner: We felt normal, loved; life took its course until suddenly Father died... Don't tell never tell if you do they'll grow up crippled Don't even whisper in their ears it's a secret none must bear. Father gave us his blessing but not his genes. We searched our faces in the mirror for what was real. We'd been made mechanically.There is much fine poetry in this issue of ENVOI. I especially liked John Latham's BLIND GOSPEL his fingers jab the air, construct geometries the sighted do no knowPhilip Sealy's thoughtful imagistic poems, Chris Beckett's wry and original lines, which surpise at each turn and leave us both laughing and sad; the simplicity and directness of Jeremy Duffield ...for the first time I remembered one kiss, your goodbye wave, and wonder how the years have spanned our lives, regret I cannot even recall your nameand Juliet Humphrey's honest and gently humorous examination of her relationship with her mum She'd put me back on the shelf and keep looking given half a chanceAlso enjoyable is Mario Petrucci's short article on poetry coteries, and there are some thoughtful and detailed reviews. There are some weak poems here as well. I found some of the writing to be sentimental and clichéd, or unnecessarily long; somtimes less IS more, as Andrew Jordan points out in a negative review of ENVOI published in this edition. However, at least editor Roger Elkin has enough open mindedness to print such feedback as this, and there are enough interesting poems to make it worthwhile buying a copy. | ||
| reviewer: Ian Seed. | ||
| Envoi #135 | ||
|
In his editorial Roger Elkin advices new poets to read widely, which is sound advice that more should follow. A new trend here, which is hotly debated in the READERS' LETTERS section, is to print biographical notes and statements by poets before their work as an introduction. This is not something I find appealling. Indeed I find it largely off-putting. Sheena Canham prefaces her work with the statement These four poems are concerned, in different ways, with ambition and control and the regrets which can be associated with having allowed such impulses to dominate from time to time. They take as their beginning different moments in people's lives and the thoughts which circle around such moments, looking backwards and forwards in time.Having read that somewhat boring introduction, I've lost the inclination to read the poems. And the way the page is laid out it is difficult not to read it before reading the poems. Eve Jackson's contributions spread over three pages, so I was able to come to her delightful poem 10 WAYS OF LOOKING AT LONG-TAILED TITS without first reading her notes which are on a previous page. Having enjoyed the poem it is OK to then turn back and learn that she is working on a series of bird poems which seems a good excuse for spending lots of time gazing out of the window. Some notes are thankfully short and Philip Waterhouse induces one to read his poems by issuing only a brief statement As unregenerate expatriate, am exploring ways to maintain non-combatancy against pressure to return to warring worlds of journalism/politics.His HEAVY ARTILLERY ends now, Buttercup, curl that big arm back to you, slow, beckoning big boy so bad in need of big breath, motion to your cushy jazz-babee, come to mama He'll fall all.One of my favourite poems from the issue is Anne Lewis-Smith's STAYING ON THE BOAT What did I expect having left the island unvisited for so long? That paths would still be bracken hid ... From the boat I saw bare well-worn tracks on the southern hill, but not our tree... | ||
| reviewer: Mandy Smith. | ||
| Envoi #136 | ||
|
Here is probably one of the liveliest and very best poetry journals around. It's self funding [no Arts Council bursaries etc]. Subscribers are encouraged to submit up to six previously unpublished poems, or a sequence, or a longer poem. Decisions usually come within 6 to 8 weeks. Unlike a lot of editors, Roger Elkin gives helpful feedback and suggests corrections if he wants you to re-submit a piece and always gives a good reason if he decides not to publish. Put simply, Elkin is one of the busiest, hard working and most helpful poetry editors in the UK today. This issue comprises 130 pages filled with 138 poems by 38 poets. All the poems are of a very high standard and, as you would expect, there is a full range of topics. From Greek mythology to the bombing of the twin towers in New York, with every conceivable stop along the way, including poems in translation. Each poet is given a small platform of between three and six poems [six is quite rare], with further space for commenting on their work [if they so choose]. I feel the latter, a recent innovation, is a mixed blessing. Sure, I like to know a little about contributors but unfortunately Elkin is currently allowing up to a full page about what brought poets to write a certain piece. I was taught "let the poem speak for itself", so feel that a short biog would be preferable. Where possibly, one writer's platform concludes with a piece that is complimentary to the first piece of the next, and so on, thus a loose string of continuity is achieved. I would say with confidence that everyone, no matter what their poetry taste, will find something really enjoyable in every copy of Envoi. Here are a few quotes. Mike Sharpe's poems use the countryside as setting. This superb vision from TIDY NATURE Aggressive barbering has clipped his military hedge to bristling contempt for mine, still hippy with neglect,Three poems by Tarek Iskander about Kennedy are highly stylised and carefully observed. This tiny extract from ZAPRUDER FRAME BY FRAME: It is a childlike film of an adult assassination. Abraham Zapruder: the last innocent photographer.THE HAMLET DIARIES by Alice Beer is a series in ten parts, where we take little peeks into private entries by King Claudius, Queen Gertrude and Hamlet himself. This from QUEEN GERTRUDE'S DIARY: THE KING'S DEATH: I could no more caress his face, always so smooth, now blistered with some horrid, leprous rash than touch a slimy, wart-encrusted toad or writhing worms.And just to prove the sheer scale of possible topics in just this single issue, here's a short quote from the second stanza of A DRESSING GOWN SPEAKS by Judy Dinnen: My pink and white flowers swell, as new life stirs. I feel him move, legs, elbows nudge against me.As well as excellent poetry there are solid reviews of all the latest leading anthologies, lots of poetry discussion, letters pages and always a new in-house quarterly competition [to help raise much-needed funds], as well as results from the last one. Envoi is for all people serious about poetry. It's both a great read and one of the places you really should be seen if you write for publication. I have no hesitation in recommending it very highly indeed. | ||
| reviewer: Steve Anderson. |